Let’s Knock Down Newton Abbot!

Creating a giant hole in the town centre to make way for Asda. Yet another supermarket where I shall not be shopping.

We must have had a town planner at some point in our post-war history who decided they did not like Newton Abbot very much. That person, possibly from somewhere like Birmingham, sought to demolish as much of it as possible, perhaps hoping that the locals wouldn’t notice (after all, we are all a bit slow and sleepy down here) or put up much of a fight (slow and sleepy – and we drink too much cider).

Our Planner seems to have had a fairly consistent idea: instead of making Newton Abbot look better – by opening up the river and making a feature of it, or restoring the market square to its former glory – let’s turn it into a museum where people can come from far and wide to witness an emporium of the worst examples of post-war architecture.

I was quite shocked when I saw how hideous the new Market Walk is: shoddily built pastel coloured ticky-tack cubes with a vaguely 70’s retro feel. They already looked hopelessly outdated the day they were opened – more like a film set for a low budget psychedelic comedy-thriller. The really house-of-horrors scary thing is, these ticky-tack cubes are actually better than what was there before! To this day I cannot figure out why they did not demolish the whole of the market walk in all of it’s hideous 70’s entirety and create something akin to the beautiful market square that existed previously, complete with its delightful London Plane trees and wooden kiosks selling all manner of quality local goodies.

Anyway, I digress. First we had the demolition of the Penn Inn lido and park to make way for a flyover that would take 40 years to build. Then there was the demolition of a beautiful and expansive market square to make way for a supermarket and the ‘Market Walk’. Then came the demolition of our bus station to be replaced by a phenomenally ugly government office block. And now we have this – more demolition to make way for another supermarket!

And before you say anything the answer is yes: Newton Abbot has many examples of fine architecture that I shall show off in another photo journal entry. Let’s hope our rampant retro-planner does not get his or her ball and chain out for a while yet…

Incidentally, the houses you can seen boarded up in Clarendon Road were due to be demolished but were reprieved at the last minute. Otherwise this was an extensive site of destruction.

Discover more from Colin Anderson

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Comments

One response to “Let’s Knock Down Newton Abbot!”

  1. Duncan H

    never a truer word spoken. I’ve written elsewhere about the destruction of Newton Abbot, pretty much on the same lines as yourself. I was on the Town Council in the 1990s, and I am modestly proud that – on the whole – we did everything possible to resist some of the worst that TDC and various monolithic developers threw at our poor old market town. That ugly and totally out of place ASDA still angers me to this day; I think it was dumped on us from Outer Space by the Vogon Constructor Fleet in The Hitch Hiker’s Guide to the Galaxy. What the hell is it supposed to be? Some sort of weird modernist open prison? The Town Council strongly favoured a rival and far more attractive and socially inclusive town centre enhancement plan, coming from a small but enthusiastic developer with a proven track record of working successfully with ‘heritage towns’ in a sympathetic manner. Needless to say, TDC dithered and dallied for months – even years – on end (I was going to say ‘connived’), and that particular company eventually cut its not inconsiderable losses in time, money and sheer bloody hard work getting all the stakeholders on board, big and small, and it gave up on us as a ‘lost cause’. And that is how we got concrete and and the worst kind of uninspiring brutalism instead. I wouldn’t lift a finger in protest if the whole lot was bulldozed tomorrow. On second thoughts, I’d drive it myself.

Any thoughts? Leave a comment!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.